ONE FINE POTION — The Literary Magic of Harry Potter by Greg Garrett (Darton Longman & Todd, 2010, supplied by Pleroma Christian Supplies); $47.80. Reviewed by MARGARET TOLLADAY.
Not another Harry Potter book, I hear you say. Well, who would have thought we would have had Harry Potter and religion in the same book. This is a Harry Potter book with a difference. Be prepared to be challenged and entranced.
One Fine Potion explores the myth and mystery surrounding the Harry Potter character and his world. Garrett argues that these world famous novels not only entertain but also teach us about deeply held truths relating to ourselves, others and the world around us.
My reading of One Fine Potion has reconfirmed that behind the story was always another. Sounds familiar! To fully understand and appreciate this volume, reading the Harry Potter saga is a necessary prerequisite.
For some this book will have ideas and themes that challenge. Garrett has not entered into the controversy that has surrounded the Harry Potter books, but has instead thematically examined the books under the umbrella of “literary magic”.
Garrett closely examines Harry Potter under the universal themes of heroism, love, family, sacrifice, community, tolerance and faith. These themes are explored with reference to the Harry Potter books, as well as incorporating references and examples from the wider world such as Christian, Islamic and Jewish traditions, well known writers such as C.S. Lewis, and scriptural references. A well-rounded mix.
Love in Harry Potter! Yes it is there, reflected in his relationships with his peers, schoolmates and acquaintances. On one scale, his relationship with Ron’s fun-filled and boisterous family, Voldemort’s cruel and twisted love, to Hermione’s empathy and love for the little ugly house elf, Kreacher. Love in all its forms is a theme that resonates through all religions and beliefs in our known world. It is the pivot point of our own relationships with others.
This is a serious read for those who are Potter fans, but also Potter critics.
Garrett calls it a “bildungsroman” (a literary term for the story of the education of a young person). In following Harry’s journey, we also follow our own journey and become educated, challenged, grow and remain or become hopeful.
Garrett sums it up by saying, “If we too live faithfully and in hope, our stories tell us someday we too will live in a world where all is well”. Do you hear whispers of the familiar?
Margaret Tolladay lives in the Far North. She is an experienced librarian who is involved in lay ministry in Auckland diocese and her home parish.